Ep. 227. Return to the Cave of Time: Week 4 You Go Knowing

This week, Matt learns a dark legend about the cave of time involving scattered piles of bones, Chris’ read takes a tragic and sudden left turn, and someone drowns! Twice!

Ep. 226. Return to the Cave of Time: Week 3 Snou Ark!

This week, Matt learns how to be agoraphobic and claustrophobic at the same time as he whizzes through space in a coffin, Chris finds an ending that is a great setup for a movie, and the brothers have a very special Krampusnacht guest!

Ep. 225. Thankschoosing 5: The Mother is On Him

Thankschoosing is upon us again! It’s time for another journey into the worst day of your life. Can it possibly get more grim than last year? Oh, absolutely!

Ep. 224. Return to the Cave of Time: Week 2 No 1 Will Die B4 Every1 Dies

This week, Matt finds Mr. Packard’s grimdarkest vision of the distant future, Chris discovers Mr, Packard’s most baffling ending, and there’s a Finish It! Discord now! (Link’s in the post!)

Ep. 223. Return to the Cave of Time: Week 1 Crudely Fashioned Shorts

New book day! Return with the brothers to the place where it all started. And ended. And had all the middles. The Cave of Time!

Ep. 222. Creeptobscare ’22: Haunted Halloween Party!

Matt is back! But don’t think that’ll stop the curse of Creeptobscare from rearing it’s mildly annoying head! The booo-thers engage in an apple juice power hour to accompany another journey to the worst Halloween party ever. It gets real sticky. Also, Matt brings his full confidence to a horror movie synonyms quiz and Chris […]

Ep. 221. Creeptobscare ’22: Could You Be a Deer with Ty!

The shadow of Creetobscare grows long as Ty from Side Character Quest joins us to find out if we could be a deer! What could be spookier?! Three deer? DON’T BE RIDICULOUS! Ty gets stuck in deer Groundhog Day, rutting territory is disputed, and vegetation is munched. Also, Ty brings a homerun D&D style quiz […]

Ep. 220. Creeptobscare ’22: Secret AgeNT Grandma with Escape This Podcast

The bells toll thrice for the third week of Creeptobscare! Dani and Bill from Escape this Podcast and Solve This Murder join to battle lizard people on a moving train as grandmas just keep popping up left and right. Also, we receive a visit from a very special surprise caller, brainstorm birthday/halloween synergy, and make […]

Ep. 219. Creeptobscare ’22: Night of a Thousand Claws with Michael Jonathan Smith

On this second week of Creeptobscare, Michael Jonathan Smith from Cobra Kai and the upcoming Twisted Metal TV series joins the spoopy fun! Chris forces him to answer the age old question, how do you boo? Also, Chris challenges Michael to a round of Scary Movie Synonyms, and a bunch of crazy kitty cats cause […]

Ep. 218. Creeptobscare ’22: Watch Out for Room 13 with Stephen C. James

Creeptobscare begins! This week, Chris escapes the cruel yoke of Matt’s talent and takes the incredible Stephen C. James for a bumpy journey through a very very bad first day of school. Also, Chris challenges Stephen to a round of Are you a Wimp or Do You Laugh at Fear?” and they uncover the dirty […]